Adventures in Pencil Integration
This picture is about two different brands of pencils. However I think the picture represents the two different brands in everything you can buy, for example a Mac or a PC. A Mac is going to cost more but it allows users to be able to use features that a PC doesn't have. While a PC will be cheaper but it might break more. Or another example could be when buying groceries. The off brand is going to be cheaper but it might not provide as many nutrients as the name brand items. Or fashion when people pay 50 dollars for a t-shirt, that t-shirt might be awesome but you can get a t-shirt that might rip a little easier for 10 dollars. So I think the Image just represents the choice between paying more or settling for less.
Why were your kids playing games
In Why were you playing games it is a blog post that tries to show how schools are to worried about standardized tests scores and not actually learning. In the post he is in a scenario where his students are doing a simulation and having fun and learning. However, the principal calls him in and tells him that he thinks it is a game and he should stop. The teacher tries to explain that it is not a game like tic tac toe it is engaging the students and allowing them to learn and have fun at the same time. I think this post is a pretty comical way to address a real problem in the education system. In which all teachers and administrators care about is results on tests instead of the students. With little comical stories like why were your kids playing games, hopefully more and more school systems will try and adopt the student first not test scores first theory.
The other post I read was Are Pencils making us narcissistic? In this post it is another story about how a teacher and his principal don't agree with how the teacher is teaching in the classroom. In the story the teacher is saying pencils but he really means the interenet. The principal is saying that he doesn't like the new way and that they should stick to the old way of doing stuff. The teacher however believes that it is better for the student to be producing for a larger audience. He finishes by saying it is essentially the same thing as when people used to write letters to their friends in the social network. The difference is this social network just allows students to write to more friends faster.
Don't teach your kids this stuff. Please?
Scott McLeod has a PHD., which makes him a doctor, and currently works as the Director of Innovation for Prairie Lake Area Education Agency 8 in Iowa. Also he helped create the UCEA Center for the Advanced Study of Technology Leadership in Education. His post is a sarcastic post that is about how he is telling teachers the disadvantages of teaching about computers. But he ends with saying go ahead don't teach your students but I will and we will compare where they are in ten to twenty years. I like the post because it stresses the importance of preparing our students by teaching them to be the most technologically literate they can be because we have no clue what will happen in the future.
Papermate is a metaphor for a PV. Ticonderoga is a metaphor for a Mac.
ReplyDeleteYou correctly identified the message (metaphor) of Mr. Spencer's post in which the principal wants him to practice "drill and memorize" activities instead of projects or other learning approaches. All to pass the tests.
You correctly identified Dr. McLeod's satire and his message: you can try to keep your kids away from technology which is fine with me. Mine will use it and speed past your kids in skills, abilities and rewards.
Well done.
Hi Michael! I really enjoyed reading your post. I agree with you that Papermate and Ticonderoga are metaphor's for the choices we make. I also like Dr. McLeod's post about teaching children technology. It is important to make sure that they are prepared for whatever the latest innovation will be in the future. Great post! =)
ReplyDeleteYou got the metaphor correct for the comic. It's a parody of all those PC vs. Mac commercials you see. I always thought those commercials were silly because I think it's just a matter of preference. It's pretty sad that the way the principle acts in "Why were your kids playing games?" mirrors how a lot of administrators act today. There are still so many people who are against technology integration, and this is going to hurt our students in the future. Our job as teachers is to prepare them for the future, and we can't do that without teaching them about technology. Great post!
ReplyDelete